It's hard to give a overall rating to a book of short stories. Some included where worth 4 or even 5 stars, and many were only 2.
My favourite was The Pony, followed in no particular order by In Coppelius's Toyshop, Cat's Paw and Epiphany. The first story, Miracle, was particularly disappointing. Still, it would have been worth it just for The Pony.